YouTube Just Got Harder, Spotify Still Doesn't Care

In short

This episode delves into significant changes affecting podcasters on YouTube and Spotify. YouTube is increasing its Partner Program requirements, making monetization harder for new creators while shifting focus to e-commerce and partnerships. Spotify's podcasting journey is reviewed, highlighting its acquisitions, platform changes, and controversial decisions like introducing a 'skip ad' button for premium users, which impacts advertisers. The speaker expresses a strong preference against using Spotify as a podcast host due to its history of broken promises and creator-unfriendly practices, while acknowledging YouTube's potential as a discovery tool despite its own challenges.

Key takeaways

• YouTube is raising its monetization thresholds for the Partner Program, requiring more watch hours and views for Shorts.
• Spotify's history in podcasting is marked by acquisitions, platform shifts, and decisions that have frustrated creators and advertisers.
• The speaker advises against using Spotify as a primary podcast host due to its track record, while suggesting YouTube can be useful for discovery.
• The core definition of a podcast relies on RSS feeds, a concept that video-centric platforms like YouTube sometimes diverge from.
• Creators should focus on building value for their audience and sponsors, rather than solely relying on platform monetization.

Chapters

1. 00:00

   Introduction to YouTube and Spotify Podcast Changes

   The speaker introduces upcoming changes to YouTube's Partner Program (YPP) and discusses the history of Spotify's podcast hosting, highlighting broken promises and potential issues for creators.

2. 01:10

   YouTube Partner Program (YPP) Updates

   Details the increased requirements for the YPP, specifically doubling the watch hour requirement from 4,000 to 8,000 hours in the last year, effective February 1, 2027. Also mentions the increased short-form video view requirement from 10 million to 20 million in 90 days.

3. 02:15

   YPP Shorts Monetization and Subscriber Thresholds

   Explains the new requirements for monetizing Shorts, including 20 million views in 90 days and maintaining 10 million views every 90 days to continue earning. Also notes the 1,000 subscriber threshold for YPP eligibility and a $100 payment threshold.

4. 02:55

   Alternative YPP Tier and YouTube Shopping

   Introduces a lower tier of YPP requiring 500 subscribers and 3,000 watch hours (or 3 million short views) to access features like YouTube Shopping and channel memberships.

5. 03:40

   Creator Earnings and Monetization Strategies

   Discusses that 67% of YouTube creators earn less than $10,000 annually. Emphasizes the importance of selling the audience's value to sponsors rather than just selling the audience.

6. 05:00

   YouTube's Shift Away from Ad Revenue

   Highlights YouTube's announcement that ads are not the primary model going forward, with a push towards e-commerce and partnerships. Mentions that YouTube expects to pay creators more in 2027 than in 2026.

7. 06:00

   Spotify's Entry into Podcasting (2015)

   Recounts Spotify's initial approach to podcasting by partnering with companies like Libsyn and Blubrry, requiring creators to go through these partners.

8. 07:30

   Spotify's Acquisition of Anchor and Direct Hosting

   Details Spotify's acquisition of Anchor for $150 million and its subsequent direct hosting of podcasts, leading to direct competition with existing partners and creating a large amount of low-quality content.

9. 09:00

   Spotify's Acquisition of Gimlet, Parcast, and The Ringer

   Discusses Spotify's significant investments in acquiring podcast networks like Gimlet, Parcast, and The Ringer, aiming to build its own exclusive content library.

10. 10:00

    Spotify's 'Greenroom' and 'Spotify Live'

    Explains the launch and subsequent rebranding of Spotify's live audio platform from 'Greenroom' to 'Spotify Live', and the acquisition of Betty Labs to support this initiative.

11. 11:30

    Spotify's 'Music + Talk' Feature and Limitations

    Describes the 'Music + Talk' feature allowing music within podcasts but notes limitations, such as content only being available on the Spotify app and requiring a paid subscription.

12. 12:30

    Spotify's Interactive Features and 'Creator Fund'

    Covers the introduction of interactive features like Q&As and polls, and the launch of a 'Creator Fund' for live audio creators, though payment mechanics were not disclosed.

13. 13:30

    Spotify's 'Podcast for Podcasters' and RSS Feed Focus

    Discusses Spotify's shift towards supporting creators directly, including the rebranding of Anchor to 'Spotify for Podcasters' and the emphasis on RSS feeds, while still encouraging users to stay within the Spotify ecosystem.

14. 14:30

    Spotify's 'Skip Ad' Button and Advertiser Concerns

    Highlights the new 'skip ad' button for premium users, raising concerns about its impact on advertisers. Compares this to YouTube's approach where creators are still paid even if ads are skipped.

15. 15:30

    The Definition of a Podcast and RSS Feeds

    Explores the fundamental definition of a podcast, emphasizing the role of RSS feeds and how YouTube's video-centric approach differs from traditional podcasting.

16. 17:00

    Conclusion and Call to Action

    The speaker concludes by reiterating their reasons for disliking Spotify as a media host and encourages listeners to consider alternatives. They also mention upcoming speaking engagements and a call for audience questions.

Get the next School of Podcasting - Podcast Tips to Plan, Launch, Grow Your Podcast recap

A short recap of every new episode, by email. Free for up to 5 shows.