The Best (and Worst) Podcast Feedback We've Ever Received

In short

This episode of 'The School of Podcasting' features Dave Jackson's 'Question of the Month' segment, where he and guests Ralph Estepp Jr., York, and Tim discuss the most constructive and destructive feedback they've received. Ralph highlights the impact of a speaking coach, York emphasizes the importance of a clear podcast title, and Tim shares how blunt criticism led to significant improvements. Dave also shares his own experiences with both helpful and unhelpful feedback, underscoring the need for actionable criticism and considering the source. The discussion revolves around how feedback, when properly processed, can be a powerful tool for growth in podcasting.

Key takeaways

• Constructive feedback, even if blunt, can be invaluable for podcast growth and improvement.
• The source and actionability of feedback are crucial factors in determining its usefulness.
• Misleading podcast titles can hinder discovery and audience engagement.
• Negative or vague feedback is generally unhelpful and should be evaluated critically.
• Proactively addressing personal challenges, like health issues, can turn potential weaknesses into strengths in content creation.

Chapters

1. 00:00

   Introduction to Question of the Month

   Dave introduces the 'Question of the Month' segment, focusing on feedback, and poses the question about the most constructive and destructive feedback received.

2. 01:00

   Guest 1: Ralph Estepp Jr. on Constructive Feedback

   Ralph shares that the best advice he received was to hire a speaking coach, which helped him find his voice and improve his delivery, transforming his podcast.

3. 02:30

   Ralph Estepp Jr. on Destructive Feedback

   Ralph discusses receiving hateful feedback about his religious affiliations and topics, which he dismisses as not constructive.

4. 03:30

   Guest 2: York on Constructive Feedback

   York explains that changing his podcast's name from 'Poetic Earthlings' to 'Welcome to Earth Stories' was the most constructive feedback, as the original name was misleading.

5. 04:30

   York's Podcast Content

   York clarifies that his podcast focuses on sci-fi themes like time travel and alien worlds, making the name change crucial for clarity.

6. 05:30

   Guest 3: Tim on Constructive Feedback

   Tim shares that Dave's feedback calling his podcast 'ugly' was initially upsetting but ultimately led to a rebranding and significant growth, highlighting the value of blunt advice.

7. 07:00

   Tim's Experience with Feedback

   Tim recounts how Dave's initial critique of his podcast name and content, though harsh, prompted him to re-evaluate and improve, leading to increased downloads.

8. 08:30

   Dave's Perspective on Feedback

   Dave emphasizes the importance of considering the source of feedback and whether it's actionable, contrasting helpful criticism with negativity.

9. 10:00

   Dave's Most Destructive Feedback

   Dave describes a one-star review from 2010 calling his podcast 'not good' and 'commercial for bad services,' noting its lack of specificity and constructive value.

10. 12:00

    The Importance of Actionable Feedback

    Dave stresses that feedback, whether positive or negative, is only valuable if it's actionable and helps in growth, contrasting vague criticism with specific suggestions.

11. 14:00

    Scott Orr's Parkinson's Feedback

    Dave discusses Scott Orr's feedback about his speech impediment due to Parkinson's, highlighting how Scott proactively addressed it in his podcast intro, making it constructive.

12. 16:00

    Dave's Personal Feedback Experience

    Dave shares a personal anecdote about falling and injuring himself, realizing the importance of paying attention to surroundings, a lesson learned through negative experience.

13. 18:00

    Conclusion and Call to Action

    Dave reiterates the value of feedback for growth and encourages listeners to engage with the 'Question of the Month' and consider how they handle feedback.

Get the next School of Podcasting - Podcast Tips to Plan, Launch, Grow Your Podcast recap

A short recap of every new episode, by email. Free for up to 5 shows.