UPDATE: The Sodder Children

In short

This episode of Crime Junkie revisits the enduring mystery of the Sodder children, five siblings who vanished in a house fire on Christmas morning in 1945. The investigation is reignited by Miranda Weeks, a descendant of the family, who has uncovered new evidence and challenges the official narrative. The episode details the events of that fateful night, the family's persistent doubts, and the new avenues of investigation prompted by Miranda's research, highlighting the unresolved questions that continue to surround the case.

Key takeaways

• The Sodder children case involves five siblings who disappeared after a house fire in 1945, a mystery that remains unsolved.
• Descendant Miranda Weeks has uncovered new evidence, prompting a re-examination of the case.
• The official explanation of the children's deaths in the fire is questioned due to numerous suspicious circumstances.
• The family has long suspected foul play or a cover-up, and Miranda's research aims to uncover the truth.
• The episode emphasizes the ongoing search for answers and the potential for new information to shed light on the mystery.

Chapters

1. 00:00

   Introduction to the Sodder Children Case

   The episode revisits the mysterious case of the Sodder children, five siblings who vanished on Christmas morning in 1945 after a house fire. This case has been a long-standing mystery debated by true crime enthusiasts and on platforms like Reddit.

2. 00:35

   A Family Connection

   The story introduces Miranda Weeks, a descendant of the Sodder family, who is the great-granddaughter of one of the older Sodder children. She has been deeply affected by the family history and the unresolved mystery.

3. 01:05

   Miranda's Investigation

   Frustrated by the lack of answers, Miranda spent the last two years researching the case, talking to family members, and digging through archives. She eventually contacted the podcast with new information.

4. 01:30

   The Night of the Fire: Christmas Eve 1945

   The narrative details the events of Christmas Eve 1945 in Fayetteville, West Virginia. George and Jennie Sodder, parents to ten children, allowed the younger kids to stay up late to play with their new Christmas gifts. The house was busy and full of life.

5. 02:15

   The Fire Begins

   Around 10:30 PM, the younger children were still awake. After a mysterious phone call and some unusual noises, Jennie Sodder noticed smoke. The fire spread rapidly, trapping five of the ten children.

6. 03:00

   Escape and Disappearance

   George and Jennie, along with five children, managed to escape. However, the other five children—Maurice, Martha, Louis, Jennie, and Betty—did not make it out. The fire consumed the house quickly.

7. 04:00

   Immediate Aftermath and Investigation

   The family and neighbors attempted to fight the fire, but the house was destroyed. The initial investigation concluded the children perished, but the lack of remains and suspicious circumstances fueled doubt.

8. 05:00

   Unanswered Questions and Family Doubts

   The family never accepted the official explanation. Issues like the phone line being cut, the ladder missing, and the fire department's delayed response raised suspicions of foul play or a cover-up.

9. 06:00

   Miranda's New Findings

   Miranda's research uncovered dozens of previously unpublished case records, suggesting the official narrative might be incomplete or inaccurate. The episode delves into these new details and theories.

10. 07:00

    The Search for Answers Continues

    The episode concludes by emphasizing the ongoing quest for truth and the possibility that someone out there holds the key to solving the decades-old mystery of the Sodder children.

Get the next Crime Junkie recap

A short recap of every new episode, by email. Free for up to 5 shows.